Marketing & Sales

How to Attract High-Paying Clients as a Health Coach When Your Audience Isn’t Engaging

Get High-Paying Clients as a Health Coach
I'm Laura

I help coaches and practitioners grow their income and impact by packaging their brilliance into a transformative signature program, learning how to sell with integrity, and developing a strategic visibility plan.

hey there!

TOp categories

Learn more

Want to attract high-paying clients as a health coach when your audience isn’t engaging? Learn how to use diagnostic sessions and solution awareness content to turn silent followers into paying clients—no big audience needed.

Are you constantly showing up on Instagram, sending out emails, and offering value, but still not landing the high-quality clients you know you can help?

It’s frustrating when you’re doing everything “right” and still not seeing results. You start wondering:

  • Am I saying the wrong thing?
  • Is my niche too narrow?
  • Do I just need a bigger following?

Here’s the truth: you don’t need more likes, views, or followers to attract high-paying clients as a health coach.

What you do need is a clear system that builds trust, increases awareness around your solution, and gives your audience an easy way to say yes.

In this post, I’m walking you through exactly how to do that, especially if your method is different from what most people have seen before.


Why You’re Not Attracting Clients (Yet)

It’s Not a Marketing Problem. It’s a Solution Awareness Problem.

Most health coaches think if they just improve their marketing, they’ll get more clients.

And while copy, visuals, and visibility all matter… they’re not the core issue.

The real reason you’re not attracting high-paying clients is this:

Your audience doesn’t understand what you do or how it solves their problem.

This is a classic solution awareness gap.

People may know they’re struggling with:

  • Bloating
  • Brain fog
  • Fatigue
  • Hormonal imbalances
  • Chronic pain
  • Emotional eating
  • Burnout

…but they have no idea that your method—whether that’s gut testing, nervous system regulation, muscle testing, functional movement, or holistic nutrition—is the thing that can help them.

They’re problem aware, but not solution aware.

Your job? Bridge the gap.


Step 1: Use a Paid Diagnostic Session to Build Trust and Bridge Awareness

Instead of trying to “convince” someone to book a high-ticket offer from a piece of content, give them a clear, low-risk first step.

Offer a paid diagnostic session that:

  • Pinpoints the root cause of their issue
  • Gives them clarity and quick wins
  • Shows how your unique method works
  • Builds their trust in you as a provider

This could be a:

  • Nutrition and symptom assessment
  • Functional movement screen
  • Hormone or stress audit
  • Metabolic health review
  • Mind-body alignment session

Price it anywhere from $100–$300, and clearly communicate that it’s a strategic entry point, not a full program.

Bonus strategy: Apply the cost of the session toward your full coaching package if they upgrade within 7 days.

This turns what used to be a free sales call into a paid, high-converting experience.


Step 2: Focus Your Content on Building Solution Awareness

If people don’t understand how your method works or why it matters, they’re never going to reach out, no matter how valuable your posts are.

That’s where solution awareness content comes in.

Great solution awareness content:

  • Shows why conventional methods haven’t worked
  • Explains what’s actually going on beneath the surface
  • Introduces your approach as a missing link
  • Gives simple, visual examples of client wins

Examples:

  • “Why calorie cutting isn’t helping you lose weight, and what to do instead.”
  • “My client was stuck in an anxiety spiral until we addressed this overlooked root cause.”
  • “Three reasons your labs are normal but you still feel awful.”

If you want to attract high-paying clients as a health coach, your content needs to educate without overwhelming and clarify without overexplaining.

Start by highlighting client stories, metaphors, or simple before-and-after breakdowns to help your audience see how your work creates change.


Step 3: Show the “Before”—Even If You Don’t Have an “After” Yet

You don’t need polished transformation stories to be effective. You just need to help people recognize themselves in your work.

If you’ve done any assessments, intake evaluations, or diagnostic sessions, share what you discovered.

Say something like:

“This client came to me with migraines and anxiety. After one session, we saw that her cortisol was flatlined and she was under-eating by 800 calories a day. She had no idea her symptoms were connected to stress and metabolism. This insight alone helped her start sleeping better within two weeks.”

You don’t need before-and-after abs or dramatic test results.

You just need to help people realize that what they’re doing isn’t working and that your method could be the thing that changes that.

Would you like to save this post?

We'll email a link to this post to you, so you can come back to it later!

Your email address is 100% safe and will never be sent spam.


Step 4: Email More Often and Make It Obvious What You Want Them to Do

If you’re only emailing your list once a week (or less), you’re not showing up enough.

Especially when it comes to building solution awareness and inviting action, email is where trust gets built.

Here’s an easy rhythm:

  • Email 1 (value): Teach or share something that builds credibility.
  • Email 2 (direct offer): Promote your diagnostic session with a clear call to action.
  • Optional Email 3 (case study or Q&A): Share a client story or common question and your response.

Keep it short and simple.

You don’t need a newsletter format or lengthy blog posts in each of your emails.

Try something like:

Subject: Still struggling with [insert symptom]?

Most of my clients feel stuck before they realize [insert solution awareness insight].
I’ve got two diagnostic spots open this week—50% off for new clients.
Want one? Reply with “YES” and I’ll send the booking link.

If they don’t see it the first time? Send it again.

Your audience is busy. It’s not your job to manage their inbox… it’s your job to show up and offer solutions.


Step 5: Make Your First Offer a No-Brainer

If you want people to say “yes” faster, you need to reduce friction and increase perceived value.

Make your diagnostic session easy to understand, easy to book, and clearly differentiated from free content.

Here’s how:

  • Name it something results-driven (e.g. “Fatigue to Focus Strategy Call” or “Root Cause Health Review”)
  • Emphasize clarity: “You’ll leave knowing what’s wrong and what to do next.”
  • Include a deadline: “Available at 50% off until [date]”
  • Offer the upgrade incentive: “Apply the cost of this session to a full coaching package if you join within 7 days.”

This makes it low-risk and high-reward. It also attracts the right people: those willing to invest in real change.


Step 6: Speak Like a Coach, Not a Marketer

One of the biggest blocks I see is perfectionism and overthinking around content.

You don’t need to “say it perfectly.” You need to say it clearly.

Think about how you’d explain the issue to a client in session.

Then… say that. On video. In a post. In an email.

That’s it.

The more you show how your method works, the faster people will believe it can work for them.


Summary: How to Attract High-Paying Clients as a Health Coach

If you’ve been spinning your wheels trying to get more traction online, the answer isn’t more likes or better hooks.

It’s more clarity and consistent action.

Here’s your roadmap:

  1. Offer a diagnostic session that builds trust and leads naturally to your signature program
  2. Create solution awareness content that bridges the gap between symptoms and your method
  3. Show the behind-the-scenes process to demonstrate your value
  4. Send emails consistently that combine value and direct offers
  5. Make your session easy to book and incentivize upgrades
  6. Speak like a real human, not a marketing robot

You don’t need a giant audience to attract high-paying clients as a health coach.

You just need a simple system that helps people understand what you do, and experience what it’s like to work with you.

And it starts with one clear next step.


Ready to Book More Clients?

If you’re struggling to get traction, simplify everything down to this:

“Here’s the problem. Here’s why what you’ve tried isn’t working. Here’s what I do differently. Want help? Book your diagnostic session now.”

Make that your core message, and repeat it often.

That’s how you create demand. That’s how you build trust.

That’s how you attract high-paying clients as a health coach.

Want more support in implementing a strategy like this for your business? Here’s how you can work with me.

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click on a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission.

Share this with someone who needs it!

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Protected by Spam Master


WATCH NOW

How To Reach $10k+ Months With Dream Clients (And On Your Dream Schedule!)

A SPECIAL OFFER FOR ONLINE Health ENTREPRENEURS

Free training

Get my proven 3-step method so you can work less, earn more, and stop the exhausting social media hustle for good.

Your Friend and Business Mentor

I'm a women's health expert and a registered dietitian (RD) with a passion for helping goal-oriented people fuel their purpose.

I help coaches and practitioners grow their income and their impact by packaging their brilliance into transformative coaching and consulting programs, and get crystal clear on their marketing strategy.

I'm on a mission to help health business owners drop the hustle and come into alignment with their ideal business goals, so they can work from a sense of ease and abundance, and build the online business of their dreams. 

Let's get to work!

Hi, I'm Laura.

meet your mentor

Grab this!

50+ Tech Tools To Help You Run Your Online Coaching Business

Not sure what tech to use to get your business off the ground? Still trying to ducktape your business together after months (or years) of running it?

Get my list of the best free and paid tech tools to help you run your online coaching or practitioner business smoothly and efficiently, so you can focus on what you really love to do... helping your clients get healthier!

First Name

Email Address

download

Get the clarity and confidence you need to turn your expertise and passion for coaching into a wildly successful online business.

@LAURASCHOENFELDRD

© 2025 Laura Schoenfeld Coaching
All rights reserved. | Terms and Conditions 

Meet me on the 'Gram